UPCOMING EVENTS
04/15/13 SPEAKERS ON SOCIAL JUSTICE AT
WARREN WILSON
COLLEGE
The Academia and Activism Speaker Series will have a
presentation by Nithya Raman at 7 PM in Jensen Lecture Hall. For more
information call 771-2083.
04/15/13 GLOBAL DAY OF ACTION AGAINST MILITARY SPENDING
04/15/13 ACTION BY MOVE TO AMEND BUNCOMBE COUNTY
Move to Amend
Buncombe County
to ask voters on April 15th: “You pay the taxes, why do they own the
government?” MABCO members will demonstrate outside the Main Post Office and other
venues to encourage tax payers (and voters) to join the movement to get
corporate money out of politics. They will be at the Federal
Building in Asheville
from 12 – 2 PM, and at the Asheville main Post
Office from 2 – 5 PM and at Brevard
Road Mail
Sorting Center
from 4:30 – 7 PM.
04/15/13 ASHEVILLE
AS THE GO-TO PLACE
FOR SOLAR ENERGY
Time is 4 to 5:30 PM and location is the Lenoir Rhyne Board
Room of the Asheville Area Chamber of Commerce at 36 Montford Avenue in Asheville. This will be a panel presentation
on residential energy trends, solar energy systems, and brainstorming for next
steps. For more information:
http://www.blueridgesustainability.org/green-mondays-home/.
04/16/13 TRANSITION ASHEVILLE
POTLUCK
Permaculture teacher Susan Garrett will present on the
principle "Apply Self-Regulation and Accept Feedback". This principle
reminds us to make lots of small mistakes, rather than a few big ones! If we
start small, accept the feedback, and redesign, we increase our confidence to
tackle more difficult changes. Susan Garrett teaches permaculture classes at
A-B Tech, and is an active member of the Asheville-Buncombe Food Policy
Council. Remember to bring your plate, bowl, cup, utensils, and food to share.
We look forward to seeing you there! Time is 5:30 to 7 PM and location is
Community Action Opportunity office at 25 Gaston Street, Asheville.
04/17/13 ASHEVILLE
GREEN DRINKS
Future of Renewable Energy Policy in NC will be the topic
for program. It starts at 6 PM and location is Olive or Twist at 81 Broadway in
Asheville.
Presentation is by Dave Hollister, President & CEO of
Sundance Power Systems Inc. He is a renowned speaker at regional
conferences, and has been a prime mover in raising energy consciousness among
policy makers and the general public. He and one other presenter with share a
panel on state and federal renewable energy policy, including attempts to
repeal the NC Renewable Energy Incentive.
04/18/13 ISRAELI-PALESTINIAN CONFLICT FILM SERIES
This will be at the Alumni Hall at UNCA. Time is 7 PM. The
movie is “5 Broken Cameras” and the film will be followed by a discussion.
Free. For more information email hillel@unca.edu. This is sponsored by UNCA
Hillel, Belk Distinguished Professorship in the Humanities, Jewish Community
Center, and Beth HaTephila.
04/18/13 DANCE LIKE THERE’S NOBODY WATCHING
This is a fundraiser for the WNC Health Alliance. Our third
annual dance party with live music, raffle items and more. Starts at 6 PM and
the location is Altamont Brewing Company at 1042 Haywood Road in Asheville. Suggested minimum donation of $12
04/19/13 WNC PHYSICIANS FOR SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY MEETING
The next WNC PSR monthly meeting will be at a private home
near the VA Hospital. Brown Bag lunch at noon with meeting from 12:30 to 2 PM.
Everyone is welcome. Please go to
www.wncpsr.org for more information, which includes how to get there
and other details.
04/20/13 GREEN GRANNIES ‘SING FOR THE CLIMATE’
Join the Green Grannies to "SING FOR THE CLIMATE".
This is every third Saturday at 5 PM, Vance Monument.
See the video,
singfortheclimate.com.
04/20/13 EARTH DAY IN ASHEVILLE
04/20/13 CLIMATE CONVERGENCE ON RALEIGH
This is on 04/21/13 also. For more information,
http://www.climateconvergencenc.org/.
04/20/13 PROTEST U.S.
FOREST SERVICE BURN PLAN
Join us for merriment and a serious message to stop the U.S.
Forest Service from burning the Linville Gorge Wilderness. Sparky the Bear,
Friends of Linville Gorge, Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League, Protect All
Children's Environment and others will be there! Time is 2 PM and location is
the US Forest Service Supervisor’s office at 160 Zillicoa Street, Suite A in Asheville. For more
information and to sign the online petition:
http://www.savelgw.org/
04/20/13 CONFESSIONS OF A WELFARE MOTHER
Barbara Morrison will read from her book
Innocent: Confessions of a Welfare Mother, which examines welfare
stereotypes from the inside and shows the forces arrayed against women in
poverty. Following the reading will be a discussion on issues related to
poverty and single parenting. This is at 2 PM at Firestorm Café.
04/21/13 EARTH DAY - CARE OF CREATION SUNDAY VIGIL
Time is 7 PM to 8 PM at Pritchard Park.
WNC Green Congregations are bringing together diverse faith groups in an effort
to honor Creation and to urge better care for the Earth. A few speakers,
some singing, and connecting with others who care for Creation in a ritual of
candle lighting will be the main events. Concern for the children will be
a focus and the young of all ages are encouraged to join in. For more
information, contact Anna Jane Joyner at annajane@wnca.org.
04/21/13 ETHICAL SOCIETY OF ASHEVILLE
“Humanism and Ethical Culture: Alike and Different” will be
presented by Jackie Simms, Ethical Culture Officiant and Humanist Celebrant, at
the Sunday, April 21st meeting of the Ethical Society of Asheville 2:00-3:30
PM, at the Friends Meeting House, 227 Edgewood Road in North Asheville. All are
welcome! For more information contact: asheville@aeu.org,
www.aeu.org, ethicalsocietyasheville@gmail.com or 828 687-7759.
04/22/13 TRANSITION ASHEVILLE
MOVIE
The FCUCC Earth Team, the UNCA Student
Environmental Center,
and Transition Asheville are sponsoring a movie called "The Age of
Stupid" at 6:55 PM at UNCA's Karpen Hall. The Age of Stupid is a 90-minute
film about climate change, set in the future. Oscar-nominated Pete
Postlethwaite stars as a man living alone in the devasted world of 2055,
looking back at “archive” footage from 2007 and asking: "Why didn’t we
stop climate change when we had the chance?"
04/22/13 EARTH DAY EARTH SABBATH
Time is 7 to 8 PM and location is St. Mary’s Episcopal
Church (in the new hall), 337
Charlotte St. All are welcome. The Earth Sabbath
is a time to step out of our daily hectic lives and into a joyful celebration
of the mystery and meaning of the universe; a time of sharing gratitude and
appreciation for the gifts of creation; a time of lament, hope, and honoring
our interdependency; a time of reverence and humility for the power of nature
beyond our control; a time for community with people caring for creation; a
time for nurturing and supporting the vision and creativity needed for the
healing of the Earth and all those traveling upon her. For more information,
contact Jean at
larson_jean@hotmail.com.
04/26/13 SISTER PREJEAN SPEAKING – AND AN OPERA: DEAD MAN
WALKING
Sister Prejean will be speaking about abolishing the death
penalty. Time is 2:30 to 3:30 PM at Lipinski Auditorium, UNCA. The movie “Dead
Man Walking” was based on her life. Her talk will be called “Dead Man Walking –
The Journey Continues”. Free. At 8 PM, there will be a presentation of an opera
called “Dead Man Walking” (based on the book) at Lipinski Auditorium. Ticket
prices for the general public start at $25. FMI: http://cesap.unca.edu/events/dead-man-walking-opera.
There will also be a performance at WCU on 04/27/13.
04/26/13 SOCIAL JUSTICE FILM AT UNITARIAN UNIVERSALIST
The film shown tonight will be “Brother Outsider, the Life
of Bayard Rustin” in conjunction with the YWCA’s Stand Against Racism events.
This film covers the life of a master strategist and tireless activist. He
brought Gandhi’s protest techniques to the American civil rights movement, and
was fired from important leadership positions because he was openly gay. 7 PM
and location is the UU at Charlotte and Edwin Streets in Asheville. Donations accepted.
04/27/13 WALK A MILE IN HER SHOES
In pursuit of a community free from sexual violence, Our
VOICE serves all individuals in Buncombe
County affected by sexual
assault through counseling, advocacy, and education. To Register for the walk
and for more information, go to http://walkamileasheville.org/.
Cost is $15. You can purchase High Heal shoes for $15 at Hip Replacements at 72 North Lexington Avenue
04/27/13 HARD 2 RECYCLE EVENT
Time is 8 AM to 1 PM and location is 161 S Charlotte Street. Free, public
collections geared to bring awareness to other modes of recycling to our area.
Five quarterly collection days, held as special events, in part to collect and
divert items that would normally end up in the landfill, such as hard bulky
plastics, styrofoam, electronics, books, blankets, batteries, cooking oil and
much more. For more information,
http://www.ashevillegreenworks.org/hard-2-recycle.html/.
04/27/13 SECOND ANNUAL EARTH STEWARDSHIP DAY
Second Annual Earth Stewardship Day in honor of Earth Day,
10 AN – 4 PM at Blue Ridge
Community College.
Various projects will take place until 2 PM and then all participants can
reconvene until 4 PM for a large picnic and musical celebration. Come
join ECO and all its partners for a promising day of hands-on, environmental
activities that will be enjoyed throughout the county for years to come. Volunteers
should sign-up through ECO to participate in any of the projects. For more
information, go to
http://eco-wnc.org/category/calendar-events/calendar/.
04/27/13 REALLY, REALLY FREE MARKET
This will be at Aston
Park from 11 to 3 PM.
Everything free. Leftover goods go to Beloved House.
05/01/13 SIERRA CLUB MEETING
Time is 7 PM (program starts at 7:15) at the Unitarian
Universalist Church in Asheville
(corner of Charlotte & Edwin). Contact: judymattox@sbcglobal.net, or
828-683-2176 for more information.
05/02/13 VETERANS FOR PEACE MEETING
Time is 6:30 PM and location is VFP HQ at the Phil Mechanic
Studios: 109 Roberts Street
in Asheville.
VFP Chapter 099: http://vfpchapter099wnc.blogspot.com/
05/03/13 NATIONAL WAR TAX RESISTANCE GATHERING IN ASHEVILLE
The National War Tax Resistance Coordinating Committee
(NWTRCC) will hold its National Gathering, at the Flood Fine Arts Center in the
Phil Mechanics Building
at 109 Roberts Street
May 3rd through the 5th featuring workshops about War Tax Resistance, panels
and keynote addresses by Cindy Sheehan and author David Swanson. A complete
schedule of events and registration form with dates and times can be viewed at:
http://www.nwtrcc.org/gatheringMay2013.php.
David Swanson will present the keynote address on Friday May 3rd, 8pm at the
Flood Fine Arts Center, in the River Arts District, 109 Roberts St. His presentation titled,
“Lessons from an Overlooked Anti-War Movement” will center around thoughts from
his various publications including “War is a Lie.” There will be a community
potluck at 7 PM on Friday also. Cindy Sheehan's keynote address on Saturday May
4th, 8pm at the Flood
Fine Arts
Center, will detail
examples of why “War Tax Resistance IS Courage” using material from her popular
podcast titled “Cindy Sheehan's Soapbox.” How to go about refusing to pay taxes
for war will be part of the program allowing for the audience to begin to think
about alternative methods for resisting taxes going to the military. THERE IS A
NEED FOR HOSTS TO PROVIDE HOUSING - PLEASE CONTACT LOCAL ORGANIZERS AT
NEWSOUTHNETWORK@GMAIL.COM OR CALL 828-301-6683.
05/06/13 GREEN PARTY MEETING
The Buncombe County GREEN Party's business meeting is open
to the public. It is held on the first Monday of the month. Time is 6 PM and
location is the Fortune
Building (upstairs), at 729 Haywood Rd., West Asheville. Parking in back and on the
street. Contact Ronald @ 828-LUCK-180 or Larry @ 828-225-4347 for more
information.
05/09/13 ASHEVILLE
RISING MEETING
Time will be 7 PM, location to be determined. More
information to come.
05/10/13 CHILD WATCH TOUR – HOUSING MATTERS FOR KIDS
The tour, cosponsored by Children First/CIS and the Junior
League of Asheville, offers a "field trip for adults" that educates
and inspires leadership around important children and youth issues in our
community. This year we'll explore how safe, affordable housing is a
cornerstone for children's health and education. How can we make smart
investments and policy decisions around housing? Join us on May 10th to find
out. Time is 8:30 AM to 1:30 PM. Registration is limited, go here: http://statevoices.salsalabs.com/o/512/p/salsa/event/common/public/?event_KEY=430
05/13/13 MOVE TO AMEND BUNCOMBE COUNTY
Time is 7 PM and location is Unitarian Universalist
Congregation of Asheville at Charlotte and Edwin Streets in the lower level
meeting room. It shall be the mission of Move to Amend Buncombe County to
create public demand for passage by the US Congress and ratification by the
North Carolina Legislature, and those of other states, of a Constitutional
Amendment reserving access to First Amendment protections to natural human
beings and the press, defining speech as actual communication and authorizing
Congress to regulate the raising and spending of political funds. Contact Lew
at patrie.wncpsr@main.nc.us for more information.
06/01/13 RALLY FOR BRADLEY MANNING AT FORT MEADE
*******************************************
ONGOING EVENTS
*******************************************
TUESDAY
Veterans for Peace have a weekly vigil at 5 PM at Pack Square, Vance Monument
WEDNESDAY
Haywood Peace Vigilers have a weekly vigil at 4 PM at
Haywood County Courthouse in Waynesville.
THURSDAY
Asheville Homeless Network meeting at 2 PM at Firestorm
Cafe.
Police Brutality Council (discussion) at 11 AM at Firestorm
Cafe.
FRIDAY
Women in Black have a weekly vigil at noon at the City Hall
in Hendersonville
SATURDAY
Transylvanians for Peace and WNC Physicians for Social
Responsibility have a weekly vigil at noon in front of the courthouse in
Brevard.
*******************************************
ACTIONS AND READINGS
*******************************************
The Progressive Movement is a PR Front for Rich Democrats
by JOHN STAUBER
There is good news in the
Boston Globe today for the managers, development directors, visionaries,
political hacks and propaganda flacks who run “the Progressive Movement.” More easy-to-earn and easy-to-hide soft money,
millions of dollars, will be flowing to them from super rich Democrats and
business corporations. It will come clean, pressed and laundered through
Organizing for Action, the latest incarnation of the Obama Money Machine which
has recently morphed into a “nonpartisan non-profit corporation” that will
‘‘strengthen the progressive movement and train our next generation of
leaders.’’
Does this information concern you? If not, you need to
get out of the propaganda bubble of your Progressive Movement echo chamber and
think. Think hard. Think about fundamental, radical, democratic, social and
economic change, who might bring it about and how. Ask yourself if the rich
elite, the 1%, are going to fund that. Leave The Nation and Mother Jones on the
shelf; turn off Ed Schultz, Rachel Madow and Chris Hayes; don’t open that
barrage of email missives from Alternet, Media Matters, MoveOn, and the other
think tanks; and get your head out of the liberal blogosphere for a couple
days.
Clear your mind and consider this:
The self-labeled Progressive Movement that has arisen over
the past decade is primarily one big propaganda campaign serving the political
interests of the the Democratic Party’s richest one-percent who created
it. The funders and owners of the Progressive Movement get richer and
richer off Wall Street and the corporate system. But they happen to be
Democrats, cultural and social liberals who can’t stomach Republican policies,
and so after bruising electoral defeats a decade ago they decided to buy a
movement, one just like the Republicans, a copy.
The Progressive Movement that exists today is their success
story. The Democratic elite created a mirror image of the type of
astroturf front groups and think tanks long ago invented, funded and promoted
by the Reaganites and the Koch brothers. The liberal elite own the Progressive
Movement. Organizing for Action, the “non-partisan” slush fund to train the new
leaders of the Progressive Movement is just the latest big money ploy to
consolidate their control and keep the feed flowing into the trough.
The professional Progressive Movement that we see reflected
in the pages of The Nation magazine, in the online marketing and campaigning of
MoveOn and in the speeches of Van Jones, is primarily a political public
relations creation of America’s richest corporate elite, the so-called 1%, who
happen to bleed Blue because they have some degree of social and environmental
consciousness, and don’t bleed Red. But they are just as committed as the
right to the overall corporate status quo, the maintenance of the American
Empire, and the monopoly of the rich over the political process that serves
their economic interests.
RICH DEMOCRATS TO PROGRESSIVES: WE LOVE YOU, MAN!
After the 2000 presidential election, the Al Gore Hanging
Chad Debacle, rich liberal Democratic elite began discussing, conspiring and
networking together to try and make sure that no scruffy, radical political insurgency
like the Nader 2000 campaign would again raise its political head. They
generally loved Al Gore, the millionaire technocrat, and they put in play
actions which led to the creation of a movement of their own that aped the
right wing’s institutions. They reached out to the well-paid professionals
who ran the big environmental groups they already funded and owned, and to
other corporate reform and liberal media operations. They followed plans drawn
up by Democratic Party insiders who wanted nothing more than to win elections,
and who saw the need for the tools and groups and campaigns the Right wielded.
They made it clear there would be wonderful financial rewards and career
advancements for progressive leaders and their organizations who lined up with them.
The Progressive Movement we see today was created by a small
group including Democratic political operatives and foundations including TIDES
(formed in 1976), the millionaires and billionaires of the Democracy
Alliance, (formed in 2005) and eventually the Obama machine.
After Al Gore’s 2000 debacle, the rich liberal Democrats in
the East and the West began to talk and meet. The green elite funders and dot.com millionaires of the Bay Area solidified
relationships with the Beltway think tanks, political consultants and and PR
flacks. Liberal Democratic Party players like MoveOn’s co-founder Wes Boyd and
TIDES Drummond Pike drew closer with others including the George Soros, John
Podesta and Stanley Greenberg crowd. The Democratic Party defeats in 2002 and
2004 fueled further despair and solidified plans for the elite to build a new
Progressive Movement that would serve their agenda.
This became very visible with the arrival of the Democracy
Alliance. A summer 2005 article in the
Washington Post made clear their intent to pour millions into
creating and owning a Progressive Movement. Looking back, someone needs to give
these folks an award because the wealthy elitists in the Democracy Alliance
succeeded wildly, mission accomplished!
As the Washington Post reported, “at least 80 wealthy
liberals have pledged to contribute $1 million or more apiece to fund a network
of think tanks and advocacy groups to compete with the potent conservative
infrastructure built up over the past three decades. The goal of the alliance,
according to organizers, is to foster the growth of liberal or left-leaning
institutions equipped to take on prominent think tanks on the right, including
the Heritage Foundation, the Hoover Institution, the American Enterprise
Institute and the Cato Institute, as well as such training centers as the
Leadership Institute and the Young America’s Foundation.”
The Washington Post explained, “There has been a flourishing
of new, pro-Democratic think tanks and advocacy groups in recent years. Clinton administration chief of staff John D. Podesta
established the Center for American Progress… and author David Brock helped
create Media Matters for America
last year, among others. All these groups are potential recipients of money from
alliance partners. In addition, the number of liberal bloggers on the Web has
been growing at a fast pace…. Jockeying for cash among possible recipient
organizations has already begun. Robert L. Borosage, director of the liberal
Campaign for America’s
Future, said the alliance will fund a ‘set of institutions in this city to be
in the national debate, and we would like to be one of them.’”
For almost a decade now the funders of the Progressive
Movement, the rich Democrats of the Democracy Alliance and their cliques,
networks and organizations, have employed and funded political hacks,
fundraisers, pollsters, organizers and PR flacks. Over the past ten years they
have dumped more and more money into the big feeding trough shared by the major
players of the Progressive movement. The overall goal and result has
always been to bring withering rhetorical fire and PR attacks upon the
Republican Right, while creating a tremendous fear of the Right to increase the
vote for Democrats. This has become Job #1 for the Progressive Movement. No one
quite remembers Job #2.
Real movements are not the creation of and beholden to
millionaires. The Progressive Movement is astroturf beholden to the rich
elite, just as the Democratic millionaires and operatives of the Democracy
Alliance intended. The “movement’s” funding is in the hands of a small
number of super rich Democrats and union bureaucrats and advisors who run with
them. Its talking points, strategies, tactics and PR campaigns are all at the
service of the Democratic elite. There is no grassroots organized
progressive movement with power in the United States, and none is being
built. Indeed, if anything threatens to emerge, the
cry “Remember Nader!” arises and the budding insurgency is marginalized or
coopted, as in the case of the Occupy
Wall Street events. Meanwhile, the rich elite who
fund the Progressive Movement, and their candidates such as Barack Obama, are
completely wedded to maintaining the existing status quo on Wall Street and in
the corporate boardroom. Their well-kept Progressive Movement is adept at
PR, propaganda, marketing and fundraising necessary in the service of the
Democratic Party and the corporate elite who rule it.
One of the Progressive Movement’s key new movers and shakers
is Ilyse Hogue. Her rise out of the green movement and into the highest
echelons of Democratic power encapsulates how it all works. In 2006 Hogue was
recruited out of Rainforest Action Network by Wes Boyd of MoveOn to run their
national campaigns. Since then she has accumulated hats and desks at The
Nation, Media Matters, the Soros-funded Super PAC Public Campaign Action Fund,
and most recently the feminist lobby NARAL. Hogue is an articulate and
well-rewarded spokesperson, fundraiser and mobilizer for the new Progressive Movement.
Her network of recent employers all benefited nicely from the successful work
of the Democracy Alliance, TIDES, MoveOn, and Soros. Anyone who wonders if
there are good careers in the Progressive Movement can look at her and others
and see the answer is clearly ‘yes’.
Every well-funded movement needs an echo-chamber to pump up
its propaganda and messages, and for the Progressive Movement the Netroots
Nation bloggers, The Nation, Alternet, Mother Jones, and scores of other
journalists and pundits have filled the bill. The development of the messages
and talking points of the Progressive Movement is the realm of DC think tanks
and organizations such as Media Matters, and a small army of flacks is also
utilized including PR maven David Fenton, pollster Stanley Greenberg and
messaging guru George Lakoff.
CO-OPTING THE ANTI-WAR MOVEMENT TO WIN ELECTIONS
After the 2004 flop of the Kerry/Edwards campaign, luck
shone on the Democrats. The over-reach of the neoconservatives, the failure to
find those weapons of mass deception (sic), the endless wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, turned American public
opinion, especially among the young, against the Republicans. Growing anti-war
sentiment, which had little to do with the organized anti-war movement,
delivered to the Democrats what Governor Mario Cuomo called “The Gift.” The
horrific Iraq
war, he explained to a Democracy Alliance gathering, was the gift that allowed
the Democrats to take control of the US Congress.
It was at this point in early 2007 that the truly dark and
cynical agenda of the professional Progressive Movement and the Democratic
Party revealed itself. Under Pelosi the Democrats could have cut off funding
for Bush’s unpopular wars and foreign policy. Instead, with PR cover provided
by MoveOn and their lobbyist Tom
Matzzie, the Democratic Congress gave George Bush all the money he wanted
to continue his wars. For the previous five years MoveOn had branded itself as
the leader of the anti-war movement, building lists of millions of liberals,
raising millions of dollars, and establishing itself in the eyes of the
corporate media as leaders of the US peace movement. Now they
helped the Democrats fund the war, both betting that the same public
opposition to the wars that helped them win control of the House in 2006 could
win the Presidency in 2008.
Their bet paid off with a young, charismatic black candidate
backed from his beginnings by Wall Street, and thus able to out-raise even the
Clinton Machine for the big money provided by the Democratic elite. Obama
hired top online organizers and combined MoveOn’s “clicktivist” style and
expertise to both raise money and build an effective political machine.
The stock market collapse of 2008 was again like a gift for the
Democrats, showing Obama’s cool contrasted with old John McCain’s panic.
Just before the Obama victory in 2008, Alternet’s Don Hazen
interviewed Drummond
Pike, the millionaire who founded the TIDES Foundation in 1976 and a
founding member of the Democracy Alliance. The topic was TIDES upcoming
“Momentum” conference at a fancy San
Francisco hotel. The exclusive confab was
described as “an invitational gathering of progressive donors and advocates”
where “some of the most creative minds in the progressive community come
together to challenge, inspire and energize each other.” Pike said it was
“where we bring funders, leaders of key nonprofits, think tanks and activist
organizations together…We are engaged in philanthropy. We granted $93 million
dollars last year and manage grant-making for more than 400 individual and
institutional donors.” The wedding of the rich elite Democrats and the
Progressive Movement just got better and better.
OCCUPYING OCCUPY FOR WALL STREET DEMOCRATS
After Obama’s 2008 victory the Progressive Movement
celebrated itself and continued to solidify with ongoing funding from the Dem
elite, playing a significant role in delivering the White House again to the
Democrats in 2012. One of their 2012 PR front stunts to benefit the
Democrats was launched in early 2012, the “99% Spring.”
In the fall of 2011, the spontaneous street action known as
Occupy Wall Street withstood media derision long enough to earn its
respect. It’s images struck a chord during the recession. Overnight
protests in major urban areas might not have appealed to the typical Democratic
voter, but bashing the rich did. Occupy might have even threatened the
Democratic Party had it ever been able to overcome its anarchistic roots and in
some way produced a strategy and organization. But its slogan “we are the 99%”
resonated widely.
Nothing succeeds like success, and imitation is the most
sincere flattery. The Progressive Movement has plenty of bright marketers and
messengers who saw the writing on Wall Street. They decided to launch and
hype an election year PR campaign to co-opt the message and theme of Occupy Wall
Street. They called it the 99% Spring, “Spring”
as in the time of year but also as in Arab Spring of 2011. When you don’t have
a real Movement of your own, at least cop good language from some others!
What amused me most about the 99% Spring was its
simultaneous audacity and vacuousness, and how obviously it was a front for
MoveOn, Van Jones, and the messaging agenda of the Democratic Party. And now
it’s all gone, just a flash across the webpages of The Nation and Mother Jones,
not even a website left behind with its web address up for sale to the highest
bidder. The Progressive Movement lives from PR campaign and to PR
campaign. When the money’s spent, the movement just pivots to the next bit
of funding and a new campaign is launched.
I first heard of the 99% Spring in a February, 2012 email
from the group formerly known as SmartMeme, activists who work with the
Progressive Movement and develop “stories” that can be used to get everyone
thinking alike in a positive way. They wrote: “This spring is our
opportunity to take the emerging movement for the 99% to next level by
following in the foot steps of previous successful movements and prepare for
organized campaigns of sustained nonviolent direct action. SmartMeme is one of
the initiating organizations of 99% spring because we believe the best way to
challenge the corporate stranglehold on our economy and political system is
with organized people power!”
Propaganda is my beat, so I was not impressed by this
revolutionary development. It sounded exactly as it was, a big flow of money
into key Progressive Movement organizations to co-opt the brand of Occupy
Wall Street movement for the Progressive Movement and the Democrats. In my
email from SmartMeme there was a hotlink to the “the99%Spring” website. Today
that link and URL goes to NameJet, a company that auctions off unwanted web
addresses. How appropriate.
The MoveOn.org site on 99%
Spring is
still up as of this writing: MoveOn pushed 99% Spring hard, and emails from
their staffers employed revolutionary hyperbole that might have made Abbie
Hoffman proud. MoveOn wrote, “groups from every corner of our movement are
joining forces to do something that’s never been tried before. During the week
of April 9-15, across America, we will bring 100,000 people together for an
unprecedented national movement-wide training on what happened to our economy,
on the history of peaceful direct action, and how — following in the footsteps
of Gandhi and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. — we can take direct action this
spring to challenge corporate power, end tax giveaways to the 1%, fight the
influence of money in politics, and more.”
99% Spring organizers Liz Butler and Joy Cushman extolled
similarly in their emails: “Imagine if the 99% of us for whom this country is
supposed to work came together as a unified movement for democracy and justice?
What could happen if hundreds of thousands of us were willing to take
nonviolent direct action to reclaim the America we love from the banks and
lobbyists who’ve stolen it from us? Let’s find out.”
The SourceWatch website: lists the
groups promoting 99% Spring: “Jobs With Justice, United Auto Workers, National
Peoples Action, National Domestic Workers Alliance,
MoveOn.org, New Organizing Institute, Movement Strategy Center, The Other
98%, Service Employees International Union, AFL-CIO, Rebuild the Dream, Color
of Change, UNITE-HERE, Greenpeace, Institute for Policy Studies, PICO National
Network, New Bottom Line, Veterans of the Mississippi Civil Rights Movement,
SNCC Legacy Project, United Steel Workers, National Education Association,
Working Families Party, Communications Workers of America, United States
Student Association, Rainforest Action Network, American Federation of
Teachers, Leadership Center for the Common Good, UNITY, National Guestworker
Alliance, 350.org, The Ruckus Society, Citizen
Engagement Lab, SmartMeme Strategy & Training Project, Right to the City
Alliance, Pushback Network, Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment,
Progressive Democrats of America, Change to Win, Grassroots Global Justice
Alliance, Campaign for America’s Future, Public Campaign Action Fund, Fuse
Washington, Missourians Organizing for Reform and Empowerment, Citizen Action of
New York, Engage, United Electrical Workers Union, National Day Laborers
Organizing Network, Alliance for a Just Society, The Partnership for Working
Families, United Students Against Sweatshops,
Presente.org, Get Equal, American Federation of State, County, and
Municipal Employees, Iowa Citizens for Community Improvement, Corporate
Accountability International, American Federation of Government Employees,
Training for Change, People Organized for Westside Renewal (POWER), Student
Labor Action Project, Colorado Progressive Coalition, Green for All, DC Jobs
with Justice, Midwest Academy, The Coffee Party, International Forum on
Globalization, UFCW International Union, Sunflower Community Action, Illinois
People’s Action, Lakeview Action Coalition, Progressive Leadership Alliance of
Nevada, International Brotherhood of the Teamsters, Resource Generation,
Highlander Research and Education Center, TakeAction Minnesota, Energy Action
Coalition, Earthhome.us.”
In any good front group campaign lists like this serve a few
purposes. One is to give the impression that this is a really powerful and
diverse effort with scores of leading organizations actively involved, rather
than a well-funded PR effort run by a small group at the top, which it was. Another
purpose is to demonstrate that there is money behind this effort and that the
major Progressive Movement hitters are involved. When I saw the list I
sent some emails to Progressive Movement activists asking why they were lending
their names to a MoveOn-driven effort to co-opt the Occupy Wall Street for the
Democrats.
Greenpeace’s Executive Director wrote back, clearly not
sharing my view. He said “something funny is happening here. In a fascinating,
good, confusing way.” He believed that MoveOn and the public employee
union SEIU were “focused on scaling civil disobedience. That’s different. You
can look at it in many ways. Friends asked us to sign on, we do that a lot.”
An employee of Campaign for America’s Future also gave 99%
Spring a big left-handed thumbs up, writing me, “this is a ton of progressive
groups trying to get a national movement going, organized, working together,”
and “anything that drives the 99% versus 1% perspective advances everything we
are trying to achieve.”
No one identified with the Progressive Movement would in any
way question or criticize the 99% Spring, at least no one I could find. And
then my inquiries uncovered someone new who has a paid position in one of the
groups. She agreed generally with my perspective, and was disgusted by
what she saw daily from her “movement”: pandering to the rich elite; shallow
public relations campaigns substituting for organizing; Democratic Party
agendas; six figure salaries and consulting fees for the Progressive executives
and consultants, and so on. She saw the Progressive Movement a convenient
way for the Democratic rich to control the rabble, manage dissent, and deflect
attention from the need for fundamental, radical structural change in the United States.
Eventually she wrote an article under the pen-name Insider
for
CounterPunch exposing the 99% Spring as a front group for the agenda of the
Democrats, organized largely by MoveOn. The Insider’s piece hit a
nerve or two and gathered quite a bit of attention and clumsy efforts at
rebuttal. I bounced the piece around and became its defender and promoter. She
quoted me in her article. I told her that the 99% Spring reminded me of
the AAEI coalition, another MoveOn front that worked with Nancy Pelosi in 2007
to see to it that the Iraq
war was funded and used as a political stick to beat Republicans in 2008. Or
the massively funded Health Care for America Now coalition backed by MoveOn in
2009 which made sure that single payer health care was ignored while the White
House pushed its pro-insurance industry legislation derided as ‘Obamacare’.”
KEEP HOPE A JIVE
Predictably the echo chamber of the Progressive Media – bloggers,
columnists and editors at The Nation, Mother Jones and Alternet and elsewhere
who get funding from the Democratic Elite – defended the honor of 99% Spring. The
Nation produced a special issue promoting it. A Mother Jones writer
claimed that it was an indication that Occupy Wall Street had co-opted MoveOn. Some
of the idealistic young green activists employed by
350.org bought heavily into
99%. That inspired Insider to take a critical look at 350.org as
a tool for Obama’s re-election.
Eventually, like all PR campaigns when the funding runs dry,
the 99% Spring simply dried up and blew away. It was nothing real, just
election year pageantry from a Progressive Movement that — as the rich of the
Democracy Alliance planned — would be a way to breathe some life into the
morbid Democratic Party. The 99% Spring showed again that the Progressive
Movement primarily exists to stick it to the Republicans, the a mirror image of
their think tanks, echo chamber media, and PR fronts that rich Democrats have
created or funded.
RIP 99% Spring. It was what we thought it was, all theater,
and co-optation, all about getting Van Jones more publicity to promote Obama.
Will any of the paid professional Progressives ever admit
so? Not as long as their careers and funding depend upon it; they can’t
afford to take off their rose-hued glasses.
More importantly, how do people who aren’t the kept,
professional Progressives go about asking the right questions, organizing the
right ways, and making the fundamental, radical structural changes that will
topple the institutional control of the 1% over our lives, communities,
politics and biosphere?
I posed that question to someone not fooled by the foibles
and feints of the Progressive Movement, my colleague Patrick Barrett, a University of Wisconsin academic who studies social
and political movements. A veteran of the 1960s civil rights and anti-war
movements, Patrick has never swooned to the spell of the Progressive Democrats.
Patrick is one of the few truly wise people I know. “What gets lost in all this
faux movement politics,” said Barrett, “is any real challenge to the
growing imbalance of social, political and economic power. Quite the contrary,
the ultimate impact of their actions is to reproduce if not aggravate that
imbalance. What we’ve got here is a deeply symbiotic relationship between a
pseudo-movement that derives its raison d’etre and financial vitality from a
vilification of the right, which it has helped to create and without which it
would have no reason for existence. Indeed, the more extreme the right becomes,
the better it is for them, since they live off of fear-mongering. To oppose the
right in a meaningful sense would put them out of business. That isn’t to say
that there is nothing to be feared in the right or that some of these folks
don’t think they’re fighting the good fight, but rather that the two work in
tandem, much like a good-cop-bad-cop team. As the right becomes ever more
extreme, this Democratic Party cum non-profit industrial complex moves further
and further to the right itself, thereby giving the Republicans and their ilk
ever greater leash and making it easier to frighten the “progressive” masses.”
Barrett concluded, “Lest anyone think that this is some kind
of conspiracy theory, it’s important to emphasize that this is primarily a
function of social and economic structures and political institutions that
create a market for these sorts of pseudo-movement leaders, who will flourish
if the conditions are right. That’s why we need to focus our attention on
altering those conditions, something these people have little or no interest in
doing.”
John Stauber is an independent writer, activist and author. His
books include
Toxic Sludge Is Good for You, Mad
Cow USA and
Weapons of Mass Deception. In 1993 he founded the Center for Media and
Democracy to expose corporate, political and media propaganda campaigns. He
retired from the Center in 2008.
No comments:
Post a Comment